The best spare tire mounting bracket depends on where you need to carry or store the tire. The GADFISH and Qualward brackets are trailer-tongue options for wheels with specified lug patterns; the Homydom and black wall-mount models attach to a trailer or garage wall. The Anina bracket serves a different purpose: it mounts an antenna behind a compatible Jeep’s spare tire, not a spare wheel. Compare mounting location and fit before choosing.
| Product | Best For | Key Detail |
|---|---|---|
| GADFISH Spare Tire Carrier | Trailer tongue mounting | Several lug patterns; up to 150 lb |
| Homydom Wall Mount | Enclosed trailers and garages | Steel carrier with adjustable screw positions |
| Black Wall Mount Carrier | Wall storage and tire access | Includes multiple bolts and locking nuts |
| Anina Jeep Antenna Mount | JK Wrangler antenna mounting | Not a spare-wheel carrier |
| Qualward Trailer Bracket | Trailer tongues up to 4 inches wide | Forged iron; up to 150 lb |
GADFISH Trailer Spare Tire Carrier
Best for: Trailer owners who want a carrier that accommodates several common wheel lug patterns. The listed fit covers 4-, 5-, and 6-lug wheels with 4-, 4.5-, 4.75-, 5-, or 5.5-inch bolt patterns. The product name states a maximum load of 150 pounds and describes a heavy-duty lock holder.
Choose this if its bolt pattern matches your spare and you need a trailer carrier. Its stated 150-pound capacity is useful for comparing it with brackets that do not list a load limit. The available details do not specify the trailer-tongue dimensions, so confirm the mounting arrangement before buying.
Homydom Enclosed Trailer Wall Mount
Best for: Enclosed-trailer or garage owners who want to store a wheel on a wall rather than on a trailer tongue. This heavy-duty steel carrier is designed to mount against an interior wall. Its special chute allows screws of different lengths to be changed without removing the fixed wall board, and a wing nut secures the tire.
The wider bracket and included instructions are useful details for buyers prioritizing a stable, organized wall installation. Choose this if you want the mount’s parts to remain together when not in use. The listing says it fits most trailer spare tires but does not provide a specific wheel-pattern range or load rating.
Black Wall-Mount Spare Tire Carrier
Best for: Buyers who want a wall-mounted tire holder with listed hardware dimensions. The heavy-duty steel bracket has a 7-inch length and 2.4-inch width. It includes long and short bolts, washers, a wing nut, a hub nut, and two types of hex nut. The listing describes zinc-plated steel and a nylon insert lock nut.
The widened fixed plate is intended to reduce loosening and swinging, while the special chute makes it possible to change screw lengths without removing the wall board. Choose this if the stated dimensions and included hardware suit your installation. The listing does not state a maximum load or exact supported lug patterns.
Anina Jeep Spare-Tire Antenna Mount
Best for: Owners of 2007–2018 Jeep Wrangler JK and JKU Unlimited models who need a mount for a CB, amateur radio, or scanner antenna. It installs behind the existing spare tire and is described as requiring no drilling.
This is included because it is a spare-tire mounting bracket, but it is not a carrier for a spare wheel. Choose it only for the stated antenna-mounting purpose and vehicle range. Avoid it if your goal is to secure a spare tire to a trailer, wall, or vehicle.
Qualward Trailer-Tongue Spare Tire Bracket
Best for: Trailer owners whose tongue is up to 4 inches wide and 5 inches tall and whose wheel matches a listed lug pattern. The bracket fits many 4-lug wheels with a 4-inch pattern, 5-lug wheels with 4-, 4.5-, or 5-inch patterns, and 6-lug wheels with a 5.5-inch pattern. It is made from forged iron and has a black powder-coated finish.
The stated maximum load is 150 pounds. Choose this if tongue dimensions, wheel pattern, and load capacity align with your setup. Confirm your measurements; the bracket is not described as fitting every trailer tongue or wheel.
Buying Guide: How to Choose a Spare Tire Mounting Bracket
Where will the bracket attach?
Decide whether the spare belongs on a trailer tongue, an enclosed-trailer wall, a garage wall, or behind a vehicle’s existing wheel. Tongue brackets such as GADFISH and Qualward are not interchangeable with wall carriers. The Anina model is specifically an antenna mount, not a wheel holder.
Does the wheel pattern match?
Check lug count and bolt-circle diameter before ordering a trailer carrier. A 5-lug wheel can have different bolt patterns, so lug count alone is not enough. Compare the wheel’s measurements with the product’s stated range.
Will the mount fit the installation surface?
For a tongue bracket, compare the tongue’s width and height with the listed limits. For a wall mount, check the available wall space and the supplied bolt lengths. Confirm that the intended mounting surface can support the loaded tire; the product details do not establish the strength of your trailer or wall.
What load capacity and hardware are listed?
Compare the tire and wheel’s weight with the stated carrier limit. GADFISH and Qualward list a maximum of 150 pounds; the wall-mount listings do not provide a load rating in the supplied details. Review included nuts, bolts, and washers, and follow the product instructions for installation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a wall-mount bracket attach to a trailer tongue?
Not necessarily. Wall carriers are designed for wall installation, while tongue brackets use a different mounting arrangement. Choose a bracket designed for the location you have.
How do I know whether a spare tire bracket fits my wheel?
Check the lug count and bolt pattern, then compare both with the bracket’s listed specifications. Do not rely on wheel diameter alone.
Are all spare-tire brackets designed to hold a wheel?
No. Some brackets, including the Anina model, hold an antenna behind a vehicle’s spare tire rather than carrying the wheel itself.
Which listed brackets state a maximum load?
The GADFISH and Qualward trailer carriers list a maximum load of 150 pounds. The provided details for the two wall mounts do not state a load capacity.